Skip to content

Home

Startups & Work Leadership

How to get honest disagreement

Why a real doubter helps more than a pretend critic, and three moves to try · 14 min

NewNot enough ratings yet

Published 26 Sept 2026 · Last updated 17 Oct 2026

In 1961 a president asked his advisers for a yes or a no on invading Cuba. Nobody voted no, though several had doubts. Eighteen months later, the same kind of room argued its way through a nuclear crisis. Why, in experiments, an appointed devil's advocate works less well than you'd think, and three moves to get the real doubts out before you decide.

Chapters

  1. 1Nobody voted no0:33
  2. 2The same room2:38
  3. 3The pretend critic4:53
  4. 4Two fast yeses8:19
  5. 5Hear it done9:47
  6. 6Build yours11:21
  7. 7The answer12:44