How to get honest disagreement
Why a real doubter helps more than a pretend critic, and three moves to try · 14 min
NewNot enough ratings yet
Published 26 Sept 2026 · Last updated 17 Oct 2026
In 1961 a president asked his advisers for a yes or a no on invading Cuba. Nobody voted no, though several had doubts. Eighteen months later, the same kind of room argued its way through a nuclear crisis. Why, in experiments, an appointed devil's advocate works less well than you'd think, and three moves to get the real doubts out before you decide.
Chapters
- 1Nobody voted no0:33
- 2The same room2:38
- 3The pretend critic4:53
- 4Two fast yeses8:19
- 5Hear it done9:47
- 6Build yours11:21
- 7The answer12:44